Note: EMGR has moved to its own domain name. This site will remain online (but with closed comments) until roughly July 1, 2007. Please update your bookmarks to visit EMGR at its new location: eriemediablog.com.

Tuesday, October 31, 2006

The Rock & Roll of JET News!

A Very Short History of a Local News Legend.

A few posts back I made an observation that each news organization tries to stake out a unique style or point-of-view to attract a certain audience. To the average observer, all news is news and all of it is the same, but is it really?

As an example, let’s take a local news legend, WJET, and trace its roots. More than a half a century ago, a young engineer put a radio station on the air to play what was known at the time by some as “demon music that was taking the souls of our young.” Rock & Roll had not only arrived it had its own station in WJET Radio 1400.

That young engineer was Myron Jones. He knew that the new music sound was going to attract the burgeoning baby boom generation, but what about their dads and mothers who preferred Hoagy Carmichael to Elvis, Chuck Barry or (god forbid) Little Richard?

Myron thought the trick to get the widest possible audience for the new station was to put extraordinary emphasis on news. Not just a re-write from the newspaper, but fast paced snappy news that just gave the key important facts of the story and then moved on to the next one. A radio format that wasn’t afraid to break-in with local live stories from the scenes of fires, murder, car accidents, burglaries or cats living with dogs. (That’s my Bill Murray moment)

The public didn’t want a lot of details; (they could get that from the newspaper) they wanted a Jack Webb newscast, “just the facts.” Myron didn’t want to compete with the newspaper for detail which he knew would bore a listening audience faster than dead air. It became important that the 5 minute newscast be crammed with as many different stories as possible and move like thunder to the listener’s ear.

The job to accomplish this news phenomenon was given to Erie’s own version of the legendary Walter Winchell, Bob Sutherland. An excellent reporter in is own right that was also capable of teaching a new breed of broadcast newsmen the trade he had learned. He also had the godlike voice of authority which didn’t hurt either.

The combination of rock and instantly breaking news presented a powerful combination that did exactly what its young founder had hoped. While I lived as a young boy and teen through this period, it wasn’t until I had entered the local advertising scene in 1968 that I fully appreciated what this broadcaster had wrought on Erie media. The first rating book I had seen (The Pulse), had WJET far and away the number one station in every demographic from 12 to 72. The genius could be seen in viewing the hour by hour audience movement. Every time a newscast came on, that quarter hour would jump with older adults and soon after it would give way to the boomers. The net effect was to make WJET appear a solid “must buy” for any product or service for every demograhic.

Let’s fast forward to 1966 and the advent of WJET-TV. They attempted to bring the same formula (minus the live remotes not possible in those days) but not with the same results. WICU was the longtime TV powerhouse with a bevy of mature and sophisticated announcer/anchors who really knew the TV medium.

What happened to Bob Sutherland? Bob didn’t change but TV changed the perception of the image that listeners had of Bob. My professors in college used to call that the power of radio to create “theater of the mind.” It really was similar to the impact that talking motion pictures had on silent film stars. The magic was broken when Valentino spoke with a high pitched voice and the same with Bob Sutherland when he wasn’t the handsome stud that everyone had pictured him to be.

The basic formula was still kept to get as many stories in as possible. Nobody knew this better than Eric Johnson who came from WICU to manage a major makeover of the WJET TV news operation. While the faces changed and a new trend of “happy news” delivery was born, the original formula that inspired WJET radio was fine-tuned for television. Eric determined that the first 7 minutes of news was critical to get and hold an audience. (Sound familiar now?) The idea was to get as many news stories of fires, crashes and political goings on at city hall in those first few minutes as possible. Again just the pertinent facts or basics were all that was important.

This revamping took a decade to accomplish its goal but eventually became the number one news leader that still holds to the last rating book. (Except at 11)

As did Bob Sutherland decades before, Eric Johnson mentored a new group of young broadcast journalist. One from that class is now the latest news director of WJET TV, Lou Baxter.

The formula has gone though some adjustments as other media have adjusted to meet the JET competition. The basic elements of getting as many stories as possible with the bare facts are still really the essential part of the WJET news strategy.

If you don’t believe me, take a few moments and TIVO the first 5 or 7 minutes of each of the local stations newscasts. You will find that, on the average, WJET TV has more stories than the other two stations.

Don’t get me wrong. I am not saying the other stations are incorrect in what they do. I am just saying that this is the successful style or point-of-view that WJET TV has followed to reach an adult 18-49.

By the way, if the young Lou Baxter had his way, he might have wanted to be one of those professional dancers on “Dancing with the Stars” instead of a news director in Erie. I hear he can do a wicked Samba.

Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


Want To Really Wakeup The Political Establisment Next Tuesday? Vote Out All Incumbents…Regardless of Party.

Monday, October 30, 2006

Don’t Mess With The FCC And The Public File!

(Editor’s Note: Last week, two posters wrote that they had written complaints to one of the local TV stations. One EMGR reader decided to test the reality of the public file each station is required to keep.

They went to the specific station and asked to see the public file to see if their letter was actually included. They were denied access and told that it was a maintenance issue.

The rules are pretty clear that the file must be available during normal business hours for public inspection. (Unless certain letters never make it to the official file for one reason or another)

A third EMGR reader, who seems very proficient in FCC broadcast regulations, posted advice to the other two readers and to anyone else who may want to also complain. (Not that it will do you any good) His or her post also included a link to fines and other penalties the FCC imposed on broadcast outlets for violating the public file regulations.

I thought the response was well written and gave excellent information and advice. I decided to reprint it for today’s post.)



It's always best to go right to the source :-)

The full text of the FCC rules regarding the public file for commercial broadcasters is in CFR 73.3526 (for noncommercial broadcasters, it's in CFR 73.3527).

Here is a tiny URL link to CFR 73.3526 which applies to WSEE and the other commercial stations in town [radio as well as TV]:

http://tinyurl.com/y73zdm

A PDF of the actual regulations will be displayed. Take a look for yourself.

Also, the FCC has a writeup entitled "The Public and Broadcasting", coincidentally a copy of which must be included in the public file. Must reading for participants of this blog and informed citizens in general. You can access it at http://tinyurl.com/ygqcfq

or just Google for it. Among lots of other stuff, it basically summarizes CFR 73.3526.

Finally, the FCC website has information on filing a complaint related to a station's
public file.

Click on http://tinyurl.com/ylz6vj

There is also a "more information" link on that page which will take you to a list of stations who have recently been fined (or whatever) for public file problems so you can see that the FCC is not joking around about this.

Here is a cut & paste from the above webpage but I urge you to go access it & read it for yourself:

"Complaints alleging the failure of a broadcast station to maintain a complete public inspection file, or to make such file available for public inspection during normal business hours, should be sent to the Federal Communications Commission, Investigations & Hearings Division, 445 12th Street, SW, Washington, DC
20554. Complaints should include the call sign and location of the station, and the address where complainant attempted to view a public file. The complaint should also describe the circumstances surrounding the complainant's inability to gain access to the station's public inspection file, or to view or obtain certain documents required to be maintained in that file, including the date and time complainant attempted to inspect the file and the specific documents which
the complainant was unable to view or obtain."

I hope this information is helpful.

--Anonymous—


Thank you Mr. or Mrs. Anonymous wherever you are>


Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final
deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC
http://www.dtv.gov/

A Special Thanks to Ohio Media Watch For Their Shameless Plug of EMGR on Oct 6th.

Friday, October 27, 2006

NBC Places “Deal” In Top 10!



Top 10 Prime Time TV Shows Week Of October 16-22, 2006

Here are the rankings for national prime-time network television last week as compiled by Nielsen Media Research. They are based on the average number of people who watched a program from start to finish. Nielsen estimates there are 283.5 million potential viewers in the U.S. ages 2 and older. Viewership is listed in millions.

Rank Program Network Viewers

1 Grey’s Anatomy ABC 22.05
2 Dancing With The Stars ABC 21.25
3 CSI CBS 20.49
4 Desperate Housewives ABC 19.71
5 Dancing W/ Stars Results ABC 19.23
6 World Series Game 2 Fox 18.16
7 CSI: Miami CBS 18.12
8 Deal or No Deal Mon NBC 17.47
9 NLCS Game 7 Fox 16.53
10 Lost ABC 16.31

• Source: ABC-TV and Nielsen Media Research data as posted on AVSFORUM.COM

Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

You Can Keep Posting Your Comments On Any Of the Past EMGR Chat Downs!

Real Men Watch Football In HD!

This Week’s HD Football

NOTE: Subject to change! (BCS 1-25 rankings are official. Rankings #26-42 are from Jerry Palm's collegebcs.com.) All times are Eastern)

NFL Weekly Coverage Maps Oct. 29 maps are now available:http://www.gribblenation.net/nflmaps/

Friday, Oct 27

Texas El Paso (4-3) at #28 Tulsa (6-1) 8:00 PM ESPN2-HD

Saturday, Oct. 28

Northwestern (2-6) at #2 Michigan (8-0) 12:00 PM ESPN-HD
Illinois (2-6) vs. #18 Wisconsin (7-1) 12:00 PM ESPN2-HD
#19 Oklahoma (5-2) at #20 Missouri (7-1) 12:00 PM (regional) ABC-HD
#27 Georgia (6-2) at #6 Florida (6-1) 3:30 PM CBS-HD
#36 Miami (5-2) at #24 Georgia Tech (5-2) 3:30 PM (regional) ABC-HD
Florida State (4-3) at #41 Maryland (5-2) 7:00 PM
ESPN2-HD #11 Tennessee (6-1) at #33 South Carolina (5-2) 7:45 PM ESPN-HD

Sunday, Oct. 29

San Francisco (2-4) at Chicago (6-0) 1 PM FOX-HD
Atlanta (4-2) at Cincinnati (4-2) 1 PM FOX-HD
Arizona (1-6) at Green Bay (2-4) 1 PM FOX-HD
Seattle (4-2) at Kansas City (3-3) 1 PM FOX-HD
Baltimore (4-2) at New Orleans (5-1) 1 PM CBS-HD
Tampa Bay (2-4) at New York Giants (3-2) 1 PM FOX-HD
Jacksonville (3-3) at Philadelphia (4-3) 1 PM CBS-HD
St. Louis (4-2) at San Diego (4-2) 4 PM FOX-HD
Indianapolis (6-0) at Denver (5-1) 4:15 PM CBS-HD
Dallas (3-2) at Carolina (4-3) 8:15 PM NBC-HD
N C A A: Connecticut (3-4) at #14 Rutgers (7-0) 8 PM ESPN-HD

Monday, Oct. 30

New England (5-1) at Minnesota (4-2) 8:30 PM ESPN-HD

Tuesday, Oct.31

UAB at SMU 7:30 PM ESPN2-HD

Wednesday, Nov. 1

Fresno State at Boise State 8 PM ESPN-HD

Thursday, Nov. 2

West Virginia at Louisville 7:30 PM ESPN-HD

Friday, Nov. 3

Air Force at Army 8:00 PM ESPN2-HD

Saturday, Nov. 4

North Carolina at Notre Dame 2:30 PM NBC-HD
U C L A at California 8 PM (Regional) ABC-HD?

(From Marc Berman’s Thursday, October 26, 2006, Programming Insider column at Mediaweek.com ) as posted on AVSFORUM.com by Fredfa

Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

ABC Quick Steps Slightly Ahead of CBS Wedneday. FOX Washed Out of Series is #4

Thursday, October 26, 2006

There Are No Virgins In Erie City Hall!

So Why Are The Media Giving This Administration The Honeymoon Treatment?

ANOTHER EMGR CHAT DOWN!

Since the Sinnott administration has taken office, Erie continues to hemorrhage jobs and companies.

It is not the mayor’s fault that companies decide to leave, but he has to take the responsibility for not working harder and creatively to replace them as well as any others that might leave in the near future. (Yes…that is a real possibility)

The number one priority for the long term health of this community, meaningful private sector economic development, seems to have been put on the back burner by the politicians, civil authorities and even the local media. The perception, rightly or wrongly, is that the city administration has been given a media pass or an extended honeymoon.

Where are the really tough questions? This administration penetrated city hall 10 months ago. It is no longer a virgin.

In last Sunday’s Erie Times-News, Pat Howared appears to be saying that the news media has given this administration a longer honeymoon because of “Filippi Fatique”? Give me a break!
“The contrast of Sinnott's earnest steadiness seemed welcome in a city afflicted by Filippi fatigue. But 10 months in, the new mayor hasn't laid out much of an agenda beyond surviving the current fiscal year, and his next-to-no-profile style hasn't prepared the community for the wrenching choices and challenges ahead. “

Most will agree with Howard that the city needs leaders who will speak the truth, but sighting “Filippi Fatigue” is like the neo-conservatives blaming past administrations for the current political malaise.

It's my opinion that the media has a larger responsibility than just reporting what goes on before their eyes and re-writing prepared news releases from City Hall. It shouldn’t take 10 months for this administration to begin addressing economic recovery and laying out its plan.

The local media does a great job in reporting the job losses and how taxpayers get taken over and over again by slick quasi developers who promise the moon. From the governor on down, they can’t shovel the public cash fast enough just with the slightest whisper of possible job creation.
But what is the media, both print and broadcast, doing to keep the politicians feet to the fire to produce? (Other than Jeff Johns for 2 hours a day)

We have heard no concrete economic plans from Erie City, Erie County or our economic revitalization partners and agencies.

Howard’s salvo in last Sunday’s column was much needed even if it was late from “Filippi Fatigue.” His ultimate conclusion is dead on:

"Erie and the entire region need much more from Sinnott than tinkering at the margins of the city's decline. The standards for judging his performance will get more exacting, because the need for leadership has never been more acute.”
The Erie Media-Go-Round CHAT DOWN for today is…

Does the media share a responsibility to hold our elected and civil officials accountable for what they don’t do as well as for what they do?

Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

FOX World Series Gets Kicked By A Foxtrot, A Waltz And A Mambo!

Tuesday, October 24, 2006

Jekyll, Hyde And The Invisible Banker?

(Editor’s Note: From reading posts from around the broadcast community, it is hard to tell what the character of SJL/Lilly might really be. Is it the kind hearted and brilliant Dr. Jekyly who is leading two of Erie’s television stations, or is it his secret evil twin who slashes jobs and burns budgets? Perhaps there is even an invisible banker who lurks and whispers in the shadows of this media empire.

Peter Ames Carlin, a writer for the Portland Oregonian, seemed to be similarly perplexed in an article he wrote on May 21st of this year called “
As The Koin Turns.” [He preferred to think of the mystery of SJL as a CBS soap opera. I rather think of it in the “spirit” of the current season.]

Below is an excerpt from Carlin’s Mickey Spillane/Mike Hammer experience. It was written following the turmoil of SJL’s purchase of Portland station, KOIN. It is well written. Wish we could have seen this type of investigative reporting in the Erie Daily Times, but then there would be no need for EMGR would there? Look for names recognizable to some in Erie.)

The mystery buyers

At first it all seemed so predictable. Almost exactly a year ago the chief executive of Emmis Communications, the Indiana-based media conglomerate that has owned KOIN since 2000, announced that he was done with the TV business. Intent on focusing on his radio and magazine holdings, Jeff Smulyan put his 16 TV stations on the market, presumably for the consumption of still another far-flung media conglomerate.

As a major network affiliate in a major city (Portland and environs rank as the nation's 23rd-largest media market), the station attracted instant interest from potential buyers. Emmis' insistence on packaging the station with at least a few of its smaller TV stations (which would have been tougher sells on their own) removed some customers. But others were interested enough to dispatch teams of xecutives and financial analysts, who reportedly took turns measuring haunches and examining teeth at the KOIN Tower throughout the summer. At the end of September a deal was announced: Emmis would sell KOIN, KHON-TV of Honolulu and two smaller stations in the Midwest for $259 million to a team of owners consisting of the Blackstone Group and SJL Broadcast Management Group.

At which point the prevailing reaction was: Who? And, a bit more anxiously: Why?
Why would the Blackstone Group, an enormous, privately held finance group with something like $40 billion at its disposal and not a lot of previous interest in media properties, be snapping up small local TV stations? Why were they teamed up with rhis SJL company -- a company, by the way, which no one in this not-entirely-unsophisticated town had ever heard of before this moment? And it's not like anyone was making it easy to discover the answers to these questions. Blackstone, for all its riches and high-profile employees (co-founder Pete Peterson was secretary of commerce during the Nixon administration; after that he was CEO of a little investment firm called Lehman Brothers), keeps a low profile in the media. But at least it had a corporate Web site. And that put Blackstone one up on the mysterious SJL.

After a day's worth of journalistic exploration just after the sale was announced at the end of September, it first appeared that SJL was based in Montana. But that address and phone number didn't pan out, leading to a search that pointed to Montecito, Calif., a village somewhere near Los Angeles. A search of that town's records produced a general telephone number for the company's headquarters, but that rang into voicemail.

You've reached the offices of SJL and George Lilly, the machine said, cheerfully enough. Our offices are closed for vacation and will re-open on Oct. 18. The machine offered another name and contact number, but that rang to voicemail, too. A third number, for SJL chief operating officer Sandra Benton, scored paydirt: a real, live human, who answered warmly, despite having been interrupted in the middle of what sounded like a TV show. Actually, she's out now, he responded. Can I have her call you when she gets home?

Eventually Benton called back. Yes, she was a top exec at SJL, which indeed was the company that wanted to take over KOIN, along with stations in Honolulu, Wichita, Kan., and Topeka, Kan.

"We're fairly small," she said, explaining the circumstances that led to the company's entire head office being out fishin' for the first half of the month. "There are six of us, and some of us work out of our homes."

Those of us intending to write another version of the enormous-and-faceless-media-conglomerate-buys-local-station story were momentarily stymied. I mean . . . they work from home?

Obviously, SJL wasn't your father's media conglomerate. They're more like your grandfather's media conglomerate. Only now Pop-Pop's got the keys to someone else's $40 billion bank account and what was going to happen next was pretty much anyone's guess. At least until the head grandpa got back from fishing, or wherever he was vacationing.

Early returns are mixed

So let's mull this over. Could SJL really be as down-home as it seemed? And if it was, did that mean KOIN was going to be traveling back in time to the bygone days of locally owned, community-centric local broadcasting? Hey, it could happen! While the easing of government regulations in the past two decades has led to an increasingly corporate atmosphere in which profit takes precedent over content -- particularly when it comes to news -- it doesn't have to be that way.

According to Tom Rosenstiel, director of the nonprofit Project for Excellence in Journalism, some local stations have started tacking away from the flashy, trashy model used by so many corporate-owned stations, back to the Old World diet of high-fiber newscasts and loads of locally produced public interest shows. "It can be done," Rosenstiel insisted. "But it means you have to accept a 30 percent profit margin for a few years."

At which point our eyes widened. A 30 percent profit margin sounded pretty good to us. And that was the compromise figure?

"Well, the backdrop is that TV stations can make like 40 or 50 percent profits," Rosenstiel explained. That's double what you can expect from a publicly held newspaper, he continued, and four times the average in other industries. But the only way to get there is either to cut expenses -- employees, production budgets, creative ambitions -- to the bone. Either that or shoot the moon by plowing so much work and money into the station you blow all other competitors to smithereens.

Figuring that the keys to KOIN's future may very well rest somewhere in SJL's past, I let my fingers do the walking to Altoona, Pa., to the offices of WATJ-TV, which had been owned by SJL from 2000 to 2004. (Editor's Note: The company reoganized and recently sold to NEXSTAR for 56 Million) And from the moment SJL moved in the results were . . .

"Horrible!"

This from news photographer Trish Gates. Gates' tales were extraordinarily similar to those heard from employees at Charleston/Huntington's WOWK-TV regarding their two years in SJL's stable (2000-02), including 25 percent staff cuts, computer-driven studio controls that tended to crash in mid-broadcast and a corporate culture so parsimonious that checks were mailed every other week, rather than every week, to reduce costs.

This was more like it: a tale of ravenous corporation ignoring the public good all for the sake of the bottom line. After all, virtually every industry-watch story I've written in the past five years revolves around one station or another having its budgets sliced, its employees diced and/or being otherwise steered away from the actual purposes of quality broadcasting. "Typically they're thinning out the product by spreading people thinner," says Rosenstiel of the Project for Excellence in Journalism.

But then we called Cindy Plymyer, a news producer at WICU-TV in Erie, Pa., who reports that a decade of SJL ownership has done nothing but make things better for the station.

"We're in a good spot now, and I think they're very
pleased," she said. A large part of the credit, she said, goes to Brian Lilly (son of SJL President George Lilly), whose first move as station manager was to install a suggestion box so employees could air their complaints to management. But now that the station is a solid No. 2 in the market, and making moves on the top-rated station, there's not a lot to complain about. "We don't have a lot of turnover," Plymyer said. "Everyone I know is happy here."

Back at the KOIN Tower, however, the anxiety was ramping up. "Rumors are picking up that new owners SJL will jettison KOIN's news department altogether," wrote blogger Lynn Sipprelle on her Oregon Media Insider blog. "I'm also told that (one very recent top manager) is saying that 'things will get far worse' for KOIN employees . . .
These days I wonder if owners HAVE any shame."

Were such high-octane accusations truly a sign of things to come, or just more keening and wailing from panicky employees? That would be an interesting question to ask George Lilly. Once he got back from vacation, that is.

-Peter Ames Carlin: The Oregonian -
©2006 The Oregonian

So which do we have in Erie?

Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

Thursday--Another EMGR CHAT DOWN On Media Responsibility and Local Politicians. (It's the Season)

Monday, October 23, 2006

Business to Business Radio Really Works In Erie!


Another Media Profile:
Nowhere in these United States will you find a radio station quite like WPSE AM 1450. Erie radio still can find a new audience. CEO’s talking to CEO’s talking to the community.

WPSE just celebrated its 10th anniversary of its “Partners for Business” program. The former frequency was once the former home of WWGO radio with studios that stood at the tip of the Commerce Building at 12th and State Streets.

Now its home rests on the campus of Penn State Behrend, its current owner. The programming includes business news, stock information and financial advice and tips for the general public. According to their website:


Weekdays consist of BusinessTalkRadio programs such as Business Morning, Market Track, Market Wrap, financial call-in shows, Bloomberg and CNN Financial Network news, BBC World Business Reports, and stock market updates.

The programs offer in-depth analysis and investment advice, including interviews with popular business authors, consumer information, and live interviews with Conference Board economists, Fortune 500 CEOs, and leading-edge entrepreneurs.

The weekend schedule offers a wealth of programs, ranging from computer technology to health, golf, dining, and travel, as well as frequent business and financial updates. Evening and weekend sports feature CBS and Westwood One broadcasts of the NFL and NCAA, and Penn State Nittany Lions football and basketball.

But the real diversity and uniqueness comes from its “Partners for Business” program we mentioned earlier. These are local business leaders and entrepreneurs who tell their story and their goals in one minute segments that are mostly candid interviews. “Partners for Business” serves two purposes. It allows executives to talk to other executives and the community about not only what their company does but what they see as its future. This is so important. This kind of format would not survive in standard radio.

Two, it targets a select audience of upscale listeners and investors with a great deal of disposable income that wealth based advertisers love to reach. The audience is modest, but very exclusive.

The whole operation and the idea man behind WPSE is Ron Slomski. Ron has had an interesting career in radio as well as public television. His previous claim to fame was as host of a polka show he produced. (No Polish jokes…this guy is as serious as you can get.)

Ron has a great deal of help from Melanie Deppen and Val Engelleiter who make up his permantent staff. Penn State students also have an opportunity to learn the radio game first hand. The “Partners for Business” concept takes a lot of intense work from conducting the interviews follwed by the laborious task of editing the sound bites at the studio for air.

It is very interesting to note that one of the prime movers who has advised and helped WPSE in this journey is none other than the Erie radio icon himself, Myron Jones. Myron has served in the past as chairman of a special advisory committee to the station along with other broadcast and community leaders. (Disclaimer…this writer also sits on the advisory board)

Myron Jones has had a long personal goal that looks like it is finally going to be reached; moving the 1450 stick (antenna) from its current campus location to the westside of Erie in the 12th and Greengarden area. That should substantially help its signal and reach.

Rarely noticed, but what WPSE has done is unique in broadcasting today. Slomski has had many stations across the country ask him just how he did it. When they find out how much work and time is involved, their interest just sort of melts away, but total admiration for WPSE's radio entrepreneurial spirit remains real.

The station has set up strict standards for advertising from which it will accept or reject. As an example, it will not take standard “buy them up…move them out” spots or political advertising. With the exception of sports, “Partners for Business” is virtually the station’s total advertising effort. Slomski is very sensitive to his audience and the proper environment he needs to retain for his business clients and his select but growing list of listeners.
Currently, "Partners for Business" has over 125 participating local sponsors. (Wow!...That's an effort.)

WPSE won’t get rich but they make expenses and provide a service to both the business, college and the greater community at large.


Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


Local Blogaholic Blog Finds More News on Duopolies!

Saturday, October 21, 2006

CBS & ABC Dancing Alone Again In Top 10!


Top 10 Prime Time TV Shows Week Of October 2-8, 2006

(Here are the rankings for national prime-time network television last week as compiled by Nielsen Media Research. They are based on the average number of people who watched a program from start to finish. Nielsen estimates there are 283.5 million potential viewers in the U.S. ages 2 and older. Viewership is listed in millions.)

(Editor's Note: I guess Nielson hasn't updated their count to 300 Million yet)
Rank Program Network Viewers


1 Grey’s Anatomy Thurs ABC 22.88
2 CSI CBS 21.85
3 Desperate Housewives ABC 20.64
4 Dancing With The Stars ABC 20.10
5 Dancing With Stars Results ABC 18.21
6 CSI: NY CBS 17.97
7 CSI: Miami CBS 17.60
8 60 Minutes CBS 17.28
9 Lost ABC 16.89
10 Criminal Minds CBS 16.73


• Source: ABC-TV and Nielsen Media Research data as reported on AVSFORUM.com


"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


The Eye Is Still Watching Erie, But So Far--The FCC Is Holding its Tongue!

Friday, October 20, 2006

Football As It Should Be Seen…In High Definition!


This week’s HD Football



NOTE: Subject to change! (BCS 1-25 rankings are official. Rankings #26-42
are from Jerry Palm's
collegebcs.com.) All times are Eastern)NFL Weekly Coverage Maps
Oct. 22 maps are now available:
http://www.gribblenation.net/nflmaps/

Friday, Oct 20#5

West Virginia (6-0) at Connecticut (3-3) 8 PM ESPN-HD


Saturday, Oct. 21

#9Texas (6-1) at #17 Nebraska (6-1) 12 PM ABC-HD

#21 Wisconsin (6-1) at #41 Purdue (5-2) 12 PM ESPN-HD

Illinois (2-5) at #30 Penn State (4-3) 12 PM ESPN2-HD

#42-tie UCLA (4-2) at#8 Notre Dame (5-1) 2:30 PM NBC-HD

#11 Tennessee (5-1) at #34 Alabama (5-2) 3:30 PM CBS-HD

#20 Boston College (5-1) at #32 Florida State (4-2)(Regional) 3:30 PM ABC-HD?

#42-tie Washington (4-3) at #10 California (6-1) 3:30 PM FSN-HD

#16 Rutgers (6-0) at #29 Pittsburgh (6-1) 5:45 PM ESPN2HD

#19 Georgia Tech (5-1) at #12 Clemson (6-1) 7:45 PM ESPN-HD

-Fresno State (1-5) at #16 LSU (5-2) 9 PM ESPN2-HD


Sunday, Oct. 22

Pittsburgh (2-3) at Atlanta (3-2) 1 PM CBS-HD

New England (4-1) at Buffalo (2-4) 1 PM CBS-HD

Carolina (4-2) at Cincinnati (3-2) 1 PM Fox-HD

Green Bay (1-4) at Miami (1-5) 1 PM Fox-HD

Detroit (1-5) at New York Jets (3-3) 1 PM Fox-HD

Philadelphia (4-2) at Tampa Bay (1-4) 1 PM Fox-HD

Denver (4-1) at Cleveland (1-4) 4 PM CBS-HD

Washington (2-4) at Indianapolis (5-6) 4:15 PM Fox-HD

Minnesota (3-2) at Seattle (4-1) 4:15 PM Fox-HD

NCAASouth Florida (5-2) at Cincinnati (3-4) 8 PM ESPN-HD


Monday, Oct. 23

New York Giants (3-2) at Dallas (3-2) 8:30 PM ESPN-HD


(From Marc Berman’s Friday, October 20, 2006, Programming Insider column at Mediaweek.com )


Posted on AVSFORUM.com
"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/
All Baseball Playoffs and Word Series Games are in Hi-Def....But not in Erie!


The Internet is Talking Hot about Erie and Duopolies.


Is It Possible That The Erie Times-News Could Be Absorbed Within SJL or NEXSTAR?.....NAH!

(The following is from a release by the progressive (alias liberal) news blog "Common Dreams Newswire" It talks about the duopoly action that the FCC is expected to approve. It uses Erie as one of its examples. What do EMGR readers think?)


New Research Shows FCC Media Ownership Rule Changes Will Harm Local Communities -- and Democracy -- Across Nation

WASHINGTON - October 19 - Local communities across the nation will be harmed, and have fewer choices for news and views, if the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) loosens key limits on media ownership, according to new research conducted by the Media and Democracy Coalition (MDC), a coalition of national and local groups representing millions of Americans.
Research was released today by MDC member organizations in coordinated actions in the following twelve states: California, Texas, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Florida, Ohio, Washington, Oregon, Arkansas, Virginia, Montana, and Maine. The research finds that in every one of those states, most citizens already live in highly concentrated media markets with few choices for news and views. More media mergers in these highly concentrated markets will reduce already insufficient local news coverage and eliminate diverse voices and viewpoints and, in every case, exceed US Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission Merger Guidelines. Yet these mergers would be approved by the FCC under its proposed new rules with "no questions asked."

"If Americans lose access to views and news, media moguls may grow richer, but America's democracy will be poorer," says Chellie Pingree, President of Common Cause, an MDC member organization. "America's democracy works best when citizens have access to a wide diversity of views and plenty of local news. These are two of our nation's most important media policy goals."

"It is simply not acceptable that the Federal Communications Commission would approve a local media merger with 'no questions asked,' when that same merger exceeds US Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission Merger Guidelines," says Gene Kimmelman, vice president for federal and international policy at Consumers Union, another MDC member. "A healthy democracy requires that local media outlets compete with each other, not consolidate, to ensure the public has access to diverse and independent sources of news and opinion. The FCC's proposed rules are bad for consumers and bad for democracy."

"Media moguls plan to combine local broadcasting with print, cable and telecommunications outlets to create conglomerates with unprecedented power over what we see, hear and read. This report documents that if the FCC blesses these moguls' plans, they will ultimately control which voices are heard -- and which are silenced -- across America," adds Ben Scott, Policy Director of Free Press, another MDC member.

"The evidence is overwhelmingly clear that further relaxation or elimination of media ownership limits by the FCC is not in the public interest," says study author Dr. Mark Cooper, Director of Research, Consumer Federation of America, another MDC member. "This research, taken together with the FCC's own research that it suppressed, proves that media concentration in local markets, consolidation into national chains, and conglomeration across media types all harm localism and diversity in local news markets. Local TV stations and local daily newspapers continue to be the dominant sources of local news and the most influential by far. The Internet is not a significant source of local news. In fact, the few who go online for local news frequently surf to the web sites of the local TV station or the local daily newspaper. The misguided rules the FCC proposed are simply out of touch with these facts."

"Media and Democracy Coalition member organizations in a dozen states today released this research as part of the Coalition's campaign to sound the alarm to citizens in local communities about the FCC's misguided proposed rules," says Coalition Campaign Coordinator Henry DeSio. "In 2003, the FCC received over three million public comments opposing its attempt to increase media concentration. This year, from Florida to Washington to Maine to California, Coalition members are again urging all Americans to take action, and file comments at the FCC opposing its latest dangerous effort to loosen crucial media ownership limits."
These are just a few examples of what could happen in large and small media markets across the country under the FCC's proposal to loosen media ownership limits:
Sacramento is the capital of California, the largest state in the nation, with a gross domestic product larger than Brazil, Canada, or Spain. In Sacramento, the Sacramento Bee, the dominant local newspaper, could suddenly merge with any of the top TV stations: KCRA, KXTV, KOVR or KTXL.

In Dallas, a large metropolitan market and the least concentrated of the three Texas markets studied, The Dallas Morning News, the dominant newspaper in the market, could suddenly merge with KDFW, KXAS, KTVT or KXAS, the top TV stations.

Erie, Pennsylvania is a smaller media market that is already highly concentrated, like most smaller markets studied. In Erie, the lone major newspaper, the Erie-Times News, could suddenly merge with either of the top local TV stations: WJET, WICU, or WSEE.

All of these resulting combinations exceed US Dept. of Justice and Federal Trade Commission Merger Guidelines on market concentration and power. Yet they would all be allowed under the FCC's proposed new rules with "no questions asked."

This MDC study is part of the Coalition's broader response to the FCC's proposed changes to its media ownership rules. In 2003, the FCC had voted to weaken these rules, but its action was rejected by the Philadelphia-based U.S. Third Circuit Court of Appeals, in an action brought by Coalition member Prometheus Radio Project of Philadelphia.

"Bigger, fewer media outlets with less interest in local news would be bad for Pennsylvania citizens trying to decide if we have effective local government and good corporate citizens," says Beth McConnell of Philadelphia-based PennPIRG, another MDC member, commenting on the study's findings in her state. "If the FCC proposal allowing our biggest local newspapers to merge with our biggest local TV stations goes forward, Pennsylvania citizens will end up getting inadequate choices for news and viewpoints in a market that already ranks as too-concentrated based on Department of Justice guidelines."

"We need more, not fewer media outlets in California competing in the marketplace of news and ideas to help guarantee that our communities go and grow," adds Sydney Levy of Oakland-based Media Alliance, another MDC member. "If the FCC allows these mergers, it will be harder for citizens to even learn about, let alone respond to, local issues such as crime, schools and traffic."

More information about the Coalition, its members, as well as these research reports, is available at the Coalition's website, http://www.media-democracy.net.

Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

NBC expected not to order new episodes of Studio 60. According to the trades, it is underperforming.

Thursday, October 19, 2006

So Have Duopolies Been Good For The Erie Broadcast Soul?

It’s Another Erie Media-Go-Round Chat Down...Extended Edition.

NEXSTAR and SJL/Lilly would hope you would think so. In fact, NEXSTAR launched an on-air campaign hoping to help keep the FCC’s current rules on duopoly ownership of TV stations in the same market from being changed or challenged. They are very proud of their position as their website states, “NEXSTAR has an industry reputation for pioneering new initiatives, including establishing virtual duopolies in its markets…” (Duopolies… sounds like another Latin dance on “Dancing with the Stars.”)

This weeks Erie Media-Go-Round Chat Down asks…

If you had the opportunity (and you do), what would you tell the FCC about the duopoly experience in Erie? (Again pro or con…As usual responses will be edited for appropriateness when necessary)

Update: (EMGR is going to leave this post up for another day. After a reasonable period of days, the comments will be forwarded to each of the comissioners of the FCC and the policy division to let them know how you feel duopolies have helped or hurt a small market like Erie.)

Tuesday, October 17, 2006

WSEE Can Find Fortune By Playing Jeopardy!



Answer…This syndicated game program which aired in most markets at 7pm was a bigger ratings bonanza for WICU at 6 pm?

Answer…WICU News at 7 pm? (I wish I could add sound effects)


Got the Jeopardy Questions? If not...read on.


WSEE has the opportunity to shake up the Erie television scene if they just used some imagination and looked to their sister station’s history. (I know…why is Tirak even interested in helping WSEE? The truth is we need a competitive broadcast environment rather than the same old…same old formula. )

What do I mean? I wrote recently that one of the problems with local television is the horrendous influence of consultants who want to use cookie cutter answers for everything. “They do it in Peoria so they should do it in Erie.”

Years ago, WICU was one of the few stations that programmed “Wheel of Fortune” at 6 pm and local news at 7 pm. And it worked. Wheel did extremely well during the early time period against the other two newscasts. In total, the Homes Using Television (HUT) was extraordinarily high and the newscasts didn’t suffer from the competition. Everybody won.

Most surprising of all was WICU did tremendously well with news at 7pm for over 30 years. They owned the time period. In the latter years, the HUT levels were still high but the audience demographics tended to skew over the age of 50 and that was WICU’s problem. They tried to solve it with a young and inexperienced staff but then finally relented to the cookie cutter consultant's hatchet.

After years of being beaten over the head by some high priced consultants, WICU moved their news to 6 with the rest of the east coast robot pack. Now Erie was like everywhere else with Wheel and Jeopardy from 7 to 8. Robots in step.

My view is that this is old programming thinking. It was a bad decision then and remains a worse decision today in Erie with all the other options viewers have. No reason to give viewers a real choice.

For WSEE, providing a choice can represent an opportunity... if management will just think out of the box instead of keeping their nose in their butt. Today the words “counter programming” can provide viewers with an alternative they desperately seek.

That’s right! I am suggesting that WSEE go back to the original WICU formula. They own the two properties that used to be on WICU. Move Wheel to 6 pm and provide the viewers with an alternative to other news and move their newscast to 7pm. Instead of forcing the viewer to pick which newscast to watch at 6 (And WSEE always comes out at the short end), the viewer can have a true selection and provide an opportunity to later sample the WSEE newscast. WSEE would also have the luxury of another hour to prepare and update the news over what the other stations had at 6 pm.

The Wheel lead in would help the CBS Evening News. The old WICU ratings indicated that channel 12 viewers of Wheel at 6 stayed with WICU for NBC network news and then again stayed for the local news with a veteran news team. The 6:30 break brought a real premium for WICU.

Of course the content and the look of the newscast would have to be upgraded for local prime time to really make a ratings dent, but I feel it could produce better ratings than they have now. This simple programming move would not cost them an extra dime. (Actually they could save the dime and put it toward HD digital which would also give them a programming edge)

Look at Erie television history Brian and learn. Oh! Who am I kidding! This is SJL/Lilly. They have to do everything the hard way.


Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


Wednesday...An EMGR Chat Down On Multiple Station Ownership In the Same Market.

Monday, October 16, 2006

Connoisseur Media Rises Again…Like Lazarus.


Profiles In Erie Media

If anyone had radio waves running through their veins it is Jeff Warshaw, CEO and founder of Connoisseur Media. According to a March 2006 Radio INK article, Jeff’s parents and an uncle owned Universal Broadcasting. Even as a student, he purchased his first station in Indiana that began the incarnation of his company.

His in-home exposure to classic radio really set the tone for his future and that of Connoisseur Media. He is what I would call a… broadcaster. He is enthralled with the medium itself and knows how to make money in the current climate.

In a short period of time, he amassed a sharp team of second lieutenants headed by long time friend and his CFO, Mike Driscoll and Vice-President, David Bevins. In a few years, they acquired 39 stations and later sold the entire group to Cumulas Communications for 258 million.

So what do you do when you are still a relatively young man and have 258 million in your back pocket burning a hole? You build a second broadcast empire just like you did with the first except you use a different approach.

After a bit of R&R, Warshaw reassembled his crew of lieutenants and reviewed the radio market conditions. He quickly observed stations were selling for far too high multiples to make a decent return on investment in the shortest possible time. In a May interview this year with RBR/TVBR, Warshaw said, “We just couldn’t find deals that made sense for us.”

Instead, Jeff’s gang decided to do the reverse of what is usually expected--they decided to build brand new stations from scratch from FCC auctions of new frequencies. He was successful in getting 10 of 20 construction permits he sought. So the company was reborn again. (Halleluiah)

One of the exceptions to this approach was Erie. A few weeks ago, I had the opportunity to break bread with Dave Bevins, who makes his home in Cleveland but currently makes the I-90 run to Erie to monitor the former Nextmedia properties.

Bevins said that “the Erie radio properties represented a rare opportunity as they were well run, mostly competitive and well positioned in the marketplace. " (It didn’t hurt that they were selling at a favorable price or Warshaw wouldn’t have touched it with a polish kielbasa)

The reputation of Connoisseur Media in the trade and blog world is thus far rather stellar. The company seems to get a lot of respect for its decision making process, target marketing and its ability to turn a handsome profit. (Are Professor Warshaw and his lieutenants giving lessons?)

In the Radio INK interview, Jeff Warshaw explained his philosophy of radio this way: “Our creating value is not based on hitting quarterly numbers, nor is it to keep our stock prices afloat in order to fund acquisitions. As a result, we spend heavily on research and promotion. We invest continuely in our properties. We believe that is one way to build long-term value.” (That is the mark of a broadcaster and not just a bean counter.)

What advice does he give to his station’ staff? “Turn your swords away from your competitors in the radio industry and focus on growing the radio business in our community.” (I remember Myron Jones using the same philosophy)

After my conversation with VP Dave Bevins, I have a feeling we are going to see some positive changes at the former Rambaldo properties. Talk radio could be more local talk again and personalities will continue to rule the music airwaves. And we will see more radio promotion!. (That is my hope) “The Wolf” was the first signal of that change. I can say that they seem intent on learning the Erie market and not looking for cookie cutter quick solutions.

For me, that makes for exciting radio to look forward too for the listener and twice as exciting if you are advertisers.

As for the current senior management of the Erie Connoisseur stations, I had the impression that they were satisfied with what is there. Replacing Rick Rambaldo with a new GM may not be as easy. Word has it that a few at One Boston Store Place would be interested in the job and they are being considered. However, I get the feeling that this company wants the right person with multi-station experience and they are willing to take their time in reviewing their options and people including out-of-market candidates.

Time will tell.


Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


HDTV..Quality Local News Spell P-R-O-F-I-T-S!

Saturday, October 14, 2006

ABC & CBS Split Top 10! 5 & 5

Top 10 Prime Time TV Shows Week Of October 2-8, 2006

(Here are the rankings for national prime-time network television last week as compiled by Nielsen Media Research. They are based on the average number of people who watched a program from start to finish. Nielsen estimates there are 283.5 million potential viewers in the U.S. ages 2 and older. Viewership is listed in millions.)
Rank Program Network Viewers

1 GREY'S ANATOMY-THU 9PM ABC 22.80
2 CSI CBS 21.51
3 DESPERATE HOUSEWIVES ABC 20.96
4 LOST ABC 18.82
5 DANCING WITH THE STARS ABC 18.38
6 CSI: MIAMI CBS 17.90
7 DANCING W/STARS RESULTS ABC 17.49
8 NCIS CBS 15.89
9 SURVIVOR: COOK ISLANDS CBS 15.83
10 TWO AND A HALF MEN CBS 15.80
"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/
Please Pray For The Family Of Mrs. Paul Tirak!

Thursday, October 12, 2006

….And On The 7th Day He Rested, And Gave Us Football In High Definition.

This week’s HD Football !
NOTE: Subject to change! (BCS rankings are Jerry Palm's collegebcs.com.) All times are Eastern)

NFL Weekly Coverage Maps Week Six
is now available:http://www.gribblenation.net/nflmaps/

Thursday, Oct 12
#22 Virginia Tech (4-1) at #25 Boston College (4-1) 7:30 PM ESPN-HD

Friday, Oct 13
#33 Pittsburgh (5-1) at Central Florida (2-3) 8 PM ESPN2-HD

Saturday, Oct. 14
Minnesota (2-4) at #28 Wisconsin (5-1) 12 PM ESPN-HD
#13 Iowa (5-1) at Indiana (3-3) 12 PM ESPN2-HD
#1 Ohio State (6-0) at Michigan State (3-3) 3:30 PM (Regional) ABC-HD
Alabama (4-2) at Mississippi (2-4) 3:30 PM CBS-HD
#3 Florida (6-0) at # 10 Auburn (5-1) 7:30 PM ESPN-HD, ESPN2-HD (“Full Circle” coverage)
#4 Michigan (6-0) at #27 Penn State (4-2) 8 PM (Regional) ABC-HD
Arizona State (3-2) at #2 Southern California (5-0) 8 PM (Regional) ABC-HD

Sunday, Oct. 15
New York Giants (2-2) at Atlanta (3-1) 1 PM Fox-HD
Houston (1-3) at Dallas (2-2) 1 PM CBS-HD
Philadelphia (4-1) at New Orleans (4-1) 1 PM Fox-HD
Kansas City (2-2) at Pittsburgh (1-3) 1 PM CBS-HD
Miami (1-4) at New York Jets (2-3) 4:15 PM CBS-HD
Carolina (3-2) at Baltimore (4-1) 1 PM Fox-HD
Seattle (3-1) at St. Louis (4-1) 1 PM Fox-HD
Oakland (0-4) at Denver (3-1) 8:15 PM NBC-HD

Monday, Oct. 16
Chicago (5-0) at Arizona (1-4) 8:30 PM ESPN-HD

Listing from AVSFORUM.com

"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

....And He Said..."Let There Be HD Everywhere but Erie."

To Report Or Not To Report…That Is A News Director’s/Editor’s Dilemma!

Erie Media-Go-Round Chat Down on Ethics in Local Journalism!

Yesterday’s post gathered a great deal of comment. As much as I would like to think it was the provocative post itself, the comments that were generated came more by decisions that were made in various local newsrooms yesterday.

I was going to do a post on what WSEE can do to improve its evening news position. However, yesterday’s journalistic ethics controversy has trumped that. (I will leave that for next week when the smoke clears.)

Instead, feel free to continue yesterday’s discussion in the first “Erie Media-Go-Round Chat Down.” I will post both pro and con. (This is not just for broadcasting) Just watch the usual rules. I will edit where necessary.

I would like to also invite students who may read EMGR to participate as well. I am sure that those in the local media (and they do read) would be interested in the younger comments as well.

So let the first “Erie Media-Go-Round Chat Down” on Ethics in Local Journalism begin.

Wednesday, October 11, 2006

Local News Is Not Chump Change!


While major network news continues with a slide in viewers, local stations seem to have lost less viewers and increased profits.

In a 2004 report by the State Of The News Media, it states that “local news has been enormously profitable.” According to the survey the report was compiled from…local news accounts for 46% of total station revenue. Let’s say that again because it feels so good. Local news advertising revenue makes up 46% of the average total station revenue. (No wonder that local news is up from the standard hour every evening up to 2 hours) In fact, less than 10% of the stations reported that their news operations lost money.

The major question the report seems to ask “is whether the industry might be wiser if it moved in the direction of slightly lower profit margins—still usually in excess of 40% ---in order to reinvest in stronger newsgathering and experiment in new programming, as a way of attracting a younger audience.” (mmmm ... Where have we heard that before?)

So why not?

Again, according to the report, station management is playing it safe. Local news plays such a crucial role in the station's revenue that they are fearful of upsetting the golden apple cart. (Imagine that!)

So now we know why stations would be reluctant to change let alone jettison local news. “It’s the dollar stupid.” First place or last place, news still brings in the money. In any other industry when you have a leader like this, you try to protect that investment by investing more. (Ask Sumner Redstone)
Indeed many news operations are currently taking the plunge in to HD newsgathering. Most Cleveland and Pittsburgh stations have or are in the process of that conversion.

Now don’t get ahead of me here. I am not advocating that the local stations move toward local HD news. That will happen with time… a very long time. But what I am advocating is that they invest more not less in their news operation. As has been shown, it can go right to the bottom line.

I have to admit; I am a news junkie and have been since the early days of WJET radio. Local news and the “new” media were made for each other and stations need to project themselves in the new technology more than just a website. “There’s revenue in them micro bits.” All that is needed is imagination which seems to be in local short supply.

News Directors should be given more…not less resources. Local television can be exciting again. If it continues the way it currently is, it will go the way of local radio, bland and lacking local definition. (There’s that word “definition” again.)

According to the same 2004 study, local television has to wake-up and respond or they will lose that valuable-- profitable audience. “Commercial and academic surveys suggest that at least a portion of the viewers who stopped watching local television news have done so because they find it repetitive, formulaic, sensationalized or insipid.” (They must have surveyed Mark Guy Findlay) “Brand loyalty is weakening and more viewers, research suggests, are likely sampling stations and churn through them.”

Perhaps one of the closing paragraphs of the report is probably the most revealing.

“The question of local television is which way it turns. The biggest threat it faces now is the paradox of an undernourished product that is in oversupply…In trying to differentiate one product from another, stations have tended to emphasis branding instead of content.”

In my opinion, this report has Erie clearly in its sites. I am convinced that local news directors probably know the message…I am not so sure their superiors have the same perspective until they take their nose out of their cash registers and find out far to late that there is a hole in the bottom of the boat.

Bullwinkle…. Start Bailing.”


"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


Tuesday, October 10, 2006

At 83, You Can Still Think Like a Young Buck..(Maybe Make a few Too)


The Sumner Redstone, Chairman of Viacom and CBS Corp, (personal net worth 7.5 billion) interview on Charlie Rose last week was extremely revealing. The shock wave last month in broadcasting and Wall Street circles was the surprise firing of Tom Freston by Redstone. Freston, CEO of Viacom after Redstone broke the company in two, was one of the prime movers that helped build Viacom, but not fast enough for Sumner.

In the Rose interview, Charlie would not let the core issue of Freston’s firing go. He finally got Sumner to admit that the issues were two. One, the stock was under performing compared to its sister CBS Corp under its CEO, Les Moonves. Viacom's value was down 11% year over year compared to CBS Corp which was up 12% for the same period.

But the real core reason that stuck in Redstone’s crawl was he had ordered Freston to buy MySpace.com for an agreed price of 500 million. Freston baulked and Redstone’s archrival, Rupert Murdoch scooped it up for 580 million. This made Rupert again the darling of Wall Street. MySpace is currently valued at 1.5 Billion. (I guess billionaires have fragile egos)

Sumner admitted in the Rose interview, that the loss put it over the edge for him. He felt that the internet and new technologies are crucial to the future viability of his companies. (Now why can’t we get thinkers like that?)

At 83, the man still thinks 10 to 20 years ahead even if he still lives in the modest house he bought for $43,000. Not only did Viacom lose a billion dollars in equity gain via the MySpace loss, but Sumner lost a reported 700 million in the devaluation of Viacom stock. (He also lost another 113 million in the first two weeks after he fired Freston) it is no wonder that Moonves is always watching the CBS Corp stock ticker with one eye and the overnight ratings with the other.

The message is clear. For “old” media to compete, it has to learn to incorporate the “new” media and find ways to create revenue with it. If Sumner Redstone can see that and he’s 83, then there is still possible hope for SJL and Nexstar. The train is leaving the platform, who locally will be on it and who will be left at the station? (A prophetic thought)

I think I can… I think I can…I know I can…I know I can.
Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

Monday, October 09, 2006

Tit for Tat Anonymous…Or Not So Anonymous!


(Editor’s Note: The following are from two comments that were posted over the weekend. The first Anonymous poster seems to take issue with what appears to be budget cuts at WICU News and its effect on quality of content. I can't help having the suspicion that both posts are from the same place...but that is just the suspicious me. Perhaps the kettle talking to the pot?)

The second Anonymous post is signed as WICU News Management. The way their response was written, leads me to believe that it is legitimate and probably from the hand of WICU News Director Phil Hayes or John Last)


Since later in the week, EMGR will be writing more about the growing importance of local news for local stations both as image and as a profit center, I thought the below comments were relevant. It seems this subject created a great deal of interest with Mark Guy Findlay’s comments in the Erie Times-News last week)

Anonymous #1

Speaking of WICU: have you noticed that Channel 12 has stopped doing some live broadcasts during the news? No more "Band of the Week" Live from CHAMPION Ford Friday nights at 11pm. No more "Where in Erie is Julie Coates" during the WICU Morning News.I know the almighty dollar rules in TV, but why drop these? They were popular and people liked watching them. Did it REALLY cost that much? I mean I heard WICU is still paying on its FIRST live truck (purchased 1996) but this is ridiculous!

Anonymous
Friday, 06 October, 2006

Anonymous Post #2

Interesting comment posted about WICU.

There is only so much money available in a budget. There are 4 primary areas: Engineering, News, Programming and Employee Salary & Benefits. One can only do so much with what one is allowed to spend.

We do not have a bottomless pit of money from which to spend. We do the best with what we have. We do not decide what we have to spend. That is up to corporate management.

If the discretionary budget runs out in October then we are pretty much finished for the rest of the year.

There is so much more to being a news manager/director than just deciding which stories get on the 6 o'clock news. Preparing a budget (and managing said budget) takes up a good portion of my day. Add to that breaking news, personnel issues and general newsroom operations and you can see how easy it is to get burned out.

We enjoy your blog. Thank you for the forum.

--WICU News Management—
Saturday Oct 7, 2006

(Editor’s Post Script. If you read carefully between the lines, these two posters are not really that far apart. Both bemoan the changing face of local TV news and the quality sacrifices they have to accept in the name of increasing the profit margin even more. "I guess we got to get that dollar back to California where it will do the most good."

What disturbs me most about the WICU post is that news management should be concentrating its efforts on the news…not a spread sheet. That traditionally has been the job of the GM and the station comptroller . They should be the ones monitoring expenses and advising the various divisions of where they stand. That really is the primary job of the bean counter.

I agree every department has to live within a budget and news is no exception. When the budget and budget monitoring issues take up a good portion of news management’s day, it becomes disturbing and alarming. Their primary job of selecting and managing the on-air content that results in the image of the station itself can become compromised.

When the content is compromised, profits are also eventually compromised. And so the cycle continues into the vast wasteland known as broadcasting today.

It is my hope that the repeated rumors of 2007 news budget cuts will not happen. You will see more profits if you invest more…not less. That’s what the national figures show.)


"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


HDTV..Quality Local News Spell P-R-O-F-I-T-S!

Friday, October 06, 2006

Crime Wave at CBS still Strikes Gold!


Top 10 Prime Time TV Shows Week Of September 25-October 1, 2006

















(Here are the rankings for national prime-time network television last week as compiled by Nielsen Media Research. They are based on the average number of people who watched a program from start to finish. Nielsen estimates there are 283.5 million potential viewers in the U.S. ages 2 and older. Viewership is listed in millions.)



Rank Program Network Viewers

1 CSI CBS 23.77
2 Grey’s Anatomy Thu 9 PM ABC 23.48
3 Desperate Housewives ABC 21.42
4 Dancing With The Stars ABC 17.91
5 CSI: Miami CBS 17.79
6 NBC Sunday Night Football NBC 16.94
7 Survivor: Cook Islands CBS 16.84
8 Criminal Minds CBS 16.54
9 Ugly Betty ABC 16.32
10 CSI: NY CBS 16.21


(Editor's Note: How Many Really Watched Ugle Betty on ABC?)


Source: ABC-TV and Nielsen Media Research data as printed on AVSFORUM.com


"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


Opinion: Broadcast Consultants Are Cookie Cutters. If You Don't Fit In To Their Mold... They'll Try To Squeeze You In Anyway.

This week’s HD Football (In Erie...it's SD)


NOTE: Subject to change! (BCS rankings are Jerry Palm's collegebcs.com.)

(All times are Eastern)

NFL Weekly Coverage Maps Week Five is now available: http://www.gribblenation.net/nflmaps/


Friday, Oct 6

#6 Louisville (4-0) at Middle Tennessee State (3-2) 8 PM ESPN2-HD


Saturday, Oct. 7

#16 Clemson (4-1) at #26 Wake Forest (5-0) 12 PM ESPN-HD

Stanford (0-5) at #9 Notre Dame (4-1) 2:30 PM NBC

#12 L S U (4-1) at #5 Florida (5-0) 3:30 PM CBS

#11 Texas (4-1) at #13 Oklahoma (3-1) 3:30 PM ABC

(Regional)

#23 Washington (4-1) at #2 Southern California (4-0)3:30 PM FSN-HD

Michigan State (3-2) at #4 Michigan (5-0) 4:30 PM ESPN-HD

South Carolina (3-2) at Kentucky (3-2) 7 PM ESPN2-HD

#14 Tennessee (4-1) at #10 Georgia (5-0) 7:45 PM ESPN-HD

#8 Oregon (4-0) at #15 California (4-1) 8 PM ABC

(Regional)#24 Nebraska (4-1) at Iowa State (3-2) 8 PM ABC


(Regional)

Sunday, Oct. 8


Miami (1-3) at New England (3-1) 1 PM CBS-HD

Tampa Bay (0-3) at New Orleans (3-1) 1 PM Fox-HD

Washington (2-2) at NY Giants (1-2) 1 PM Fox-HD

Detroit (0-4) at Minnesota (2-2) 1 PM Fox-HD

Buffalo (2-2) at Chicago (4-0) 1 PM CBS-HD

St. Louis (3-1) at Green Bay (1-3) 1 PM Fox-HD

New York Jets (2-2) at Jacksonville(2-2) 4 PM CBS-HD

Dallas (2-1) at Philadelphia (3-1) 4:15 PM FOX-HD

Pittsburgh (1-2) at San Diego(2-1) 8:15 PM NBC-HD

Northern Illinois (3-2) at Miami of Ohio (0-5) 8 PM ESPN-HD


Monday, Oct. 9


Baltimore (4-0) at Denver (2-1) 8:30 PM ESPN-HD


• • • • • • • • • • •(From Marc Berman’s Thursday, October 5, 2006, Programming Insider column at Mediaweek.com ) Reprinted on AVSFORUM.com


"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


No FCC Decision Yet On DT-16 CP Extention.

Thursday, October 05, 2006

No More Mother’s Milk For Affiliates?



This last decade the relationship between the major television networks and their affiliated stations has gone through a metamorphosis. The networks might call it a weaning away from the network compensation tit. After decades of networks paying affiliates to carry their programs, that part of the gravy train of revenue is coming or has come to an end.

The loss of network viewers and the increased cost of production has made the typical affiliate meetings more of a gripe session than a “Look there’s Paris Hilton” star gazing and toasting the new season scenario.

The networks have taken a new attitude as evidenced by the recent comments of the new king of television Les Moonves, CBS CEO. On September 15th, Moonves did a one hour interview with Charlie Rose. In the interview, Moonves really capsulated all four major networks' feelings about compensating affiliates. He said that they (CBS) supply the affiliates with quality programming that has proven to get a substantial audience. He insinuated that it was up to the local stations to translate that into cash at the pump.

Mooves said that in 2006 that CBS will pay out the last of about 250 million to affiliates in traditional compensation. “Starting next year,” said Moonves, “that will be…”0.”

It is no secret that Mooves keeps one eye on his program ratings and the other eye on the CBS Corp. stock ticker. He knows that Sumner Redstone, Viacom and CBS chairman, doesn’t like losing money. So far this year, CBS stock is up 12%. (Yes, I bought a few shares.) Redstone last month, ousted the CEO of the Viacom division because Viacom stock went down about 11%.

The other networks have done similar negotiations with their affiliates. A few years back, FOX had a verbal tug of war with its affiliate group and there are many reports that General Electric is not happy with the profit and performance of NBC/Universal.

The result is that the network affiliates will have to fend more for themselves in this new world of “Old” and “New” media. The days of 20, 30, or 40 percent returns are really gone. Affiliates have to get real. They will have to invest to keep up to date and find creative ways to sell the product the network gives them.

Affiliates have to realize that they are now competing with Xbox, Google, Yahoo and the rest for viewer time, entertainment and advertising dollars. The affiliate bean counters will have even less to count if they don’t. The two best returns for local stations right now are HD (to keep competitive with the other new media) and local news. Investing in both, technology that the viewer can see and local news will keep the end product still desirable. Advertisers like local news. Local stations have nothing to offer but content so it better be the best in quality, substance and availability.

17 million Americans have already made the HD investment and demand is growing faster than A.C. Nielson can count. (But they are counting) Will Erie television meet the challenge? I really hope they do.

Like it or not. You've got to keep up or your going to wind up kissing somebody else’s backside.


"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/


If You Build It....They Will View.

Wednesday, October 04, 2006

Investigating Masturbation Investigating. Now There’s a Topic All Erie Wants To Know About.


Embarrassing Moment #4

Those who don’t watch the 11pm local news or use TIVO might have seen Monday’s Jon Stewart’s Daily Show investigative report on investigating masturbation in Cleveland. (See Malcom, there are topics worth covering)

Carl Monday is WKYC Channel 3’s investigative reporter and recently did an “undercover” story on masturbating in the Cleveland Public Library where he confronted the purpetrators in the act...so to speak. The folks at Comedy Central thought it would be fun to do an old Mike Wallace type sabotage. This time…sabotage the sabotager, Carl Monday. The bit was real and funny.

Carl on his own blog, put it this way:

It's 7:30am...and a "reporter" and two photographers are camped out at the end
of my driveway. Wait...isn't that my job?

The "reporter" approaches and barks out something like this......"Carl, I'm a big fan of yours. How do you like going after sleeze bags?"

This must be some kind of a joke. Well, in fact it is. The kind you find on Comedy Central. More to the point, the cable commedy icon....John Stewart Show. Yea, I know the guy is enormously popular...even hosted the Oscars....but at 11pm..I'm usually watching the local news and admit to not owning Tivo.

So that's my excuse for not immediatley recognizing the crew that confronted me the other morning (my wife was next to me in the car if you don't believe me.)

Seems Stewart's producers sent the crew to Cleveland to do a "bit" on me. They hung around all day...sticking their microphone in the faces of downtowners...and Channel 3 staffers. They hung around the station...and finally, by late afternoon...we "confronted" them...a case of dueling confrontations if you will...in the Channel 3 parking lot.

The "reporter" asked rediculous questions..and wasted no time
regressing to comments about the "library story." You can guess where the "interview" went from there.

Through the efforts of Ohio Media Watch… here is the unedited confrontation just as it happened. It looks like dualing mikes. (Carol Pella was never so lucky. But then again you never know what she really saw behind city council tables at Erie City Hall.)

Click for the Unedited Comedy Central Interview of Carl Monday.

CRAP!…. I Am On The What??


Embarrassing Moment #3

(Editor’s Note: This is a 3rd in a serious of embarrassing moments in media that commentators have shared. The one below was sent to me as Anonymous. Normally I would have liked to print the name but the story was so typical of what happens at many stations, I thought it was worth holding and sharing. If you want to share a funny or embarrassing moment, send it to emgr@verizon.net.)

I used to do afternoon drive news on WJET AM 1400.

Standard practice was for the DJ to give the newsroom a courtesy call about five till the hour during their last stop set of the hour, to let him know that news was coming up. This was always helpful, since we had our backs to the DJ while banging out news copy.

One day, Ken Tyler was on vacation and the fill-in guy didn't intercom me. The next thing I know is the news stinger sounds and I whip around to see this guy pointing at me with the on air light shining

"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

Thursday….No More Mother’s Milk for Affilates!

Tuesday, October 03, 2006

Will The new AM CP 1590 Be Competition for WCTL?



WCKJ, the new AM station that has been assigned to the Kearsarge area could possibly be run as a talk station---but perhaps gospel in content. That could explain the low power assignment that would rarely interest commercial broadcasters.

One of the owners Randy Diettrich is an ordained minister of the Ministers of Christ---Assembly of Churches. (Same home address as the license) Their website allows anyone interested in being ordained in their church to complete an on-line easy payment plan course at http://www.ordinationonline.com/ .

“OrdinationOnLine.com has recently been acquired by Ministers for Christ
Assembly of Churches, along with the Technology Based Training (TBT)
fully-automated on-line study for Ordination.Technology Based Training (TBT).
TBT is quickly replacing the traditional paper-pencil testing method. TBT makes
the entire testing process easier and the results can be more reliable. "

"TBT allows Ministers for Christ Outreach to issue exams on request and score the
results immediately for people all over the world. For the past 12 years we have
been issuing the traditional paper-pencil testing method. With the Lord’s
leading we are now issuing our exams using modern technology.”


According to one poster, Mr. Cardel Eatten of Pittsburgh PA. May have been “an on-air personality from the Erie OIC remote studios (16th & German Sts.?) of WQLN-FM back in the early to mid 1970s who used the on-the-air name of Cardel Soul. This was back when WQLN-FM had first come on the air, and they had remote studios at OIC, Mercyhurst, and Edinboro with programming in each daypart from each of them as well as NPR and shows from the main studios on upper Peach St.”

I checked with Tom McLaren who headed up radio at WQLN and he does confirm Cardel Eatten with the OIC studios but not sure if he used a different on-air name as remembered by the poster.

This is all speculation right now as I have not spoken to either of the prospective owners. The same group has also applied for a license in Harborcreek for 1230 AM but it does not appear that the commission has acted on that request.

As the main blogger in Erie already noted…wouldn’t it be odd if we got another AM station before any commercial TV station went HD? It figures!
"Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all broadcasting will stop.." FCC http://www.dtv.gov/

If You Build It….They Will View.