Note: EMGR has moved to its own domain name. This site will remain online (but with closed comments) until roughly July 1, 2007. Please update your bookmarks to visit EMGR at its new location: eriemediablog.com.

Monday, October 30, 2006

Don’t Mess With The FCC And The Public File!

(Editor’s Note: Last week, two posters wrote that they had written complaints to one of the local TV stations. One EMGR reader decided to test the reality of the public file each station is required to keep.

They went to the specific station and asked to see the public file to see if their letter was actually included. They were denied access and told that it was a maintenance issue.

The rules are pretty clear that the file must be available during normal business hours for public inspection. (Unless certain letters never make it to the official file for one reason or another)

A third EMGR reader, who seems very proficient in FCC broadcast regulations, posted advice to the other two readers and to anyone else who may want to also complain. (Not that it will do you any good) His or her post also included a link to fines and other penalties the FCC imposed on broadcast outlets for violating the public file regulations.

I thought the response was well written and gave excellent information and advice. I decided to reprint it for today’s post.)



It's always best to go right to the source :-)

The full text of the FCC rules regarding the public file for commercial broadcasters is in CFR 73.3526 (for noncommercial broadcasters, it's in CFR 73.3527).

Here is a tiny URL link to CFR 73.3526 which applies to WSEE and the other commercial stations in town [radio as well as TV]:

http://tinyurl.com/y73zdm

A PDF of the actual regulations will be displayed. Take a look for yourself.

Also, the FCC has a writeup entitled "The Public and Broadcasting", coincidentally a copy of which must be included in the public file. Must reading for participants of this blog and informed citizens in general. You can access it at http://tinyurl.com/ygqcfq

or just Google for it. Among lots of other stuff, it basically summarizes CFR 73.3526.

Finally, the FCC website has information on filing a complaint related to a station's
public file.

Click on http://tinyurl.com/ylz6vj

There is also a "more information" link on that page which will take you to a list of stations who have recently been fined (or whatever) for public file problems so you can see that the FCC is not joking around about this.

Here is a cut & paste from the above webpage but I urge you to go access it & read it for yourself:

"Complaints alleging the failure of a broadcast station to maintain a complete public inspection file, or to make such file available for public inspection during normal business hours, should be sent to the Federal Communications Commission, Investigations & Hearings Division, 445 12th Street, SW, Washington, DC
20554. Complaints should include the call sign and location of the station, and the address where complainant attempted to view a public file. The complaint should also describe the circumstances surrounding the complainant's inability to gain access to the station's public inspection file, or to view or obtain certain documents required to be maintained in that file, including the date and time complainant attempted to inspect the file and the specific documents which
the complainant was unable to view or obtain."

I hope this information is helpful.

--Anonymous—


Thank you Mr. or Mrs. Anonymous wherever you are>


Congress passed a law on February 1, 2006, setting a final
deadline for the DTV transition of February 17, 2009. Most television stations will continue broadcasting both analog and digital programming until February 17, 2009, when all analog broadcasting will stop.." FCC
http://www.dtv.gov/

A Special Thanks to Ohio Media Watch For Their Shameless Plug of EMGR on Oct 6th.

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

This may be too little too late but the same thing happened to me about 2 months ago.

I wanted to check the public file at WSEE. I had to ring the door buzzer since (I was rudely informed) the station had to secure itself.

After being inside for a few minutes I was informed the public file was not available for inspection that day.

I was told the public file was only open for inspection on Monday, Wednesday and Friday. I was at WSEE on a Tuesday.

I don't have the time to file a complaint with the FCC. My advice is to call before making a wasted trip.

I never did get to view the file.


Paul Stephenson
North East, PA

Jack Tirak said...

Paul... If you had gone on a Monday, Wednesday or Friday, I am sure they would have told you it was available only on Tuesday and Thursday.

But the fact is, if they are open for business so must the public file. Mon-Friday 9am to 5pm would be a reasonable assumption for most people.

Anonymous said...

I can remember a time when a viewer/listener could easily contact the FCC and provide verification of offensive material whether on radio or TV and an investigation would ensue.
Then again, THAT was before deregulation. I think it is laughable that the FCC comes down on only high-profile incidents concerning decency like Howard Stern and CBS for the wardrobe malfunction but the crap that is on our local airwaves is there for all to see or hear.
Exactly who do the folks at WSEE think they are? Such outright arrogance. I've turned off my TV sine there isn't a news outlet in town worth a rip. The whole industry has gone to hell. It's just taken longer (like many other national trends) to reach Erie.

Anonymous said...

I have a suggestion for the management of WSEE-TV. Why not put the public file on the internet for all the world to see?

Perhaps this will never come to be since WSEE-TV does not place correspondence in the public file? Does the Public File even exist?

Also, please update your outdated website! For the love of god please step into 2006 - or 2007 since you don't have any money to do anything creative or even pregressive.

Anonymous said...

Isn't it odd that no one from WSEE management has commented on this issue?

Come to think of it, no one from WSEE management has commented on any of the topics on this blog.

Is this the way our local TV stations operate? Has anyone tried to access the public file at WICU? WJET?

I realize that only 2 groups (SJL/Lilly & Nexstar) control all of Erie's commercial TV stations.

Does this mean that the public file has been eliminated as a cost-cutting measure?

Their silence speaks volumes!

Anonymous said...

Someone should tell Tracy Stufft (WSEE Station Manager) to have a pleasant disposition when dealing with the public.

I don't think the current group of clowns running WSEE is of a cheerful nature.

Jack Tirak said...

Management has commented on this blog from time to time and several different names.

Scott has been the only one with real balls to put his name down. That is because he has his own blog and knows that you got to take the bitter with the badder.

I give him credit for that.